I felt like I should have won this. The battle calc when this is plugged in says it should have been a win. 

You counter-attacked Umpalumpala. Attack has failed !

Name	Units	Casualties	Remaining
 Helms{}Deep`s fleet
 Shark Cruiser	  429 	  359 	  70 
 Tiger Destroyer	  588 	  0 	  588 
 D.Pike Destroyer	  688 	  0 	  688 
 D.Sting Cruiser	  532 	  0 	  532 
 Angel Battleship	  3 	  0 	  3 
 Thresher Cruiser	  5 	  1 	  4 
 Barracuda Destroyer	  18 	  0 	  18 
 Bullhead Destroyer	  6 	  0 	  6 
 Piranha Frigate	  100 	  100 	  0 
 D.Hammerhead Frigate	  8 	  8 	  0 
 
Umpalumpala`s fleet
 M.Epidote Destroyer	  1,322 	  277 	  1,045 
 M.Flysch Battleship	  9 	  9 	  0 
 G.Sapphire Destroyer	  3 	  3 	  0 
 G.Livid (r) Fighter	  4 	  4 	  0 
 Small Strafez Runner	  400 	  400 	  0 
 Strafez King	  50 	  50 	  0 
 Large Strafez Runner	  100 	  100 	  0 
 Large Strafez Fodder	  180 	  180 	  0 
 F.Spear Cruiser	  24 	  24 	  0 
 Strafez Queen	  40 	  40 	  0